|
(Published in the Idaho Business Review, February 2006)
Idaho's economy is expanding, and this is apparent especially in the
construction and real estate industries. Because of this growth
business opportunities are abundant, and many astute business owners
are jumping at a number of these opportunities. To handle these
opportunities, a frequently used businesses model entails forming
separate legal entities to run separate businesses. Oftentimes these
entities will be comprised of several individuals with differing
ownership interests.
Consider these two examples: contractors may join together to own
one corporation that performs framing services and another corporation
that does finish work, or several people may own different real estate
investment properties through different limited liability companies.
Although this business model can work very well for some business
owners and provides certain protection from liabilities, without some
form of buy-sell agreement between owners of a business there is a very
important risk that is being missed; the risk of a business blowing up
from the inside.
Buy-Sell agreements are contracts between the owners of a business
that control when and how owners can sell their ownership interest in
the business and what price will be paid, or at least how that price
will be determined. If you own a business with one or more other
people, you almost certainly should have a buy-sell, or similar
agreement in place.
One can think of a buy-sell arrangement as a prenuptial agreement
for business owners. As with any other relationship, irreconcilable
differences can develop between business owners and it is wise to
address those issues up front. Owners who have agreed on virtually
everything for years can suddenly find a key business issue on which
they completely disagree. Sometimes the "problem" is simply that the
business becomes a tremendous success, or a miserable failure, and the
owners argue about who is responsible for that success or failure.
You may respect your business partner but you do not want to be in
business with their spouse or children. Without a buy-sell agreement,
an owner's death or divorce can cause a situation in which you have
unintended business partners. This is particularly common in Idaho and
other community property states because in the event of a divorce, an
owner's spouse often can claim to have a legal interest in the business.
You
own a business and would like to reward certain valuable employees by
providing them an ownership interest in the business. You need the
right to buy back the employee's shares if they are terminated.
Conversely, the employee shareholder likely wants some assurance that,
if they are terminated or have to quit, they receive fair payment for
their shares. A well drafted buy-sell agreement will address these
issues.
Buy-sell agreements are also a very important part
of a business owner's estate plan. Most business owners have invested
significant amounts of time and money in their businesses and they seek
some assurance that they will reap the benefits of their hard work.
Buyout provisions in buy-sell agreements can help assure reasonable
payment for an owner's interest upon the retirement and or death of
that owner.
In businesses where two owners each have a 50%
ownership interest, buy-sell agreements can serve as a "tie-breaker" in
the event all efforts to agree on an issue have failed. Although
deadlocks between owners are almost always accompanied by hard
feelings, a buy-sell agreement can help by setting forth the plan by
which the owners can extract themselves from the business.
A buy-sell agreement should also set forth the terms related to any
buyout. These terms should, at the very least, include how the
ownership interest will be valued and how the business or the other
owners will pay for the shares if they are to be bought back from a
shareholder.
As attorneys, we see the unfortunate results
of people failing to put these types of agreements in place. Money is
generally tight for new businesses, but skipping out on putting a
buy-sell agreement in place is a shortcut not worth taking. You simply
never know when a business relationship may turn bad.
Spending
a little money up front on a buy-sell plan is well worth it in
comparison to the time, money and stress that comes from a fight
between co-owners when no buy-sell agreement is in place.
The ideal time to put your buy-sell agreement in place is at the
very outset. Have it drafted and executed at the same time the entity
is registered with the Secretary of State's office. However, if your
business is already up and running it is not too late. Do it now, while
business is good and all of the owners are more likely to agree. Don't
risk the possibility of having to divorce your business partner without
a business prenuptial in place.
Jonathan R. Bauer is an associate with the law firm Meuleman Mollerup
LLP. He concentrates his practice in business law
(mergers/acquisitions/sales, financing, general corporate counseling),
real estate law, and estate planning. Mr. Bauer can be reached at
208.342.6066 or by email at
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
more information at www.lawidaho.com.
|